Call Us Now
Email Us Now
Can you be arrested without Miranda being read to you? Can you be taken to jail? Can you be prosecuted? Can you even be convicted?
Unfortunately, the answer is yes to all of these questions. The Miranda rule is not absolute. Even though it’s one of the most important constitutional protections, it applies in a very narrow set of circumstances. To understand how to protect yourself and avoid trouble, keep reading.
Do Police Always Have to Read You Your Rights?
You may be surprised to learn that police don’t always have to read you your rights, even when you’re being arrested. Contrary to what many believe, you can be arrested, taken to jail, prosecuted, and even convicted without ever hearing a single word about your Miranda rights.
So, what’s the rule? Miranda rights only apply when you’re both in custody and being interrogated. This means if a police officer stops you on the street and isn’t questioning you, Miranda rights don’t come into play.
What Does “In Custody” Mean?
If a police officer approaches you and you’re not sure if you’re in custody, it’s important to ask: “Am I being arrested? Am I detained, or am I free to go?”
Miranda rights only apply if you’re in custody or its equivalent and are being interrogated. If no one is questioning you, there’s no Miranda violation.
If the Police Don’t Read Me My Rights, Is My Arrest Still Valid?
Yes. The fact that a police officer doesn’t read you your rights has nothing to do with the validity of your arrest. The purpose of Miranda is to protect against self-incrimination during questioning, not to invalidate arrests.
If you’re not being interrogated or making statements that could incriminate you, Miranda doesn’t apply.
What Should You Do When Approached by Police?
If a police officer asks you questions like, “What are you doing here?” the smartest thing you can do is not engage. If you’re not being interrogated and voluntarily talking to police, they don’t have to give you Miranda warnings.
It’s important to remember that an officer needs probable cause to arrest you, meaning they must believe a crime has been committed and that you may be responsible. Don’t provide them with a reason by talking. Remain silent.
What if a Police Officer Calls You?
Miranda rights don’t apply during phone calls. Whether you’re at home, in your car, or out fishing, if you’re not in custody, police can press you as much as they want over the phone. Even if you confess, it’s not considered custody, and Miranda warnings don’t apply.
It’s generally a bad idea to talk to a police officer on the phone.
What if You Voluntarily Go to the Police?
If you voluntarily go to a police station to clear up a misunderstanding, the police aren’t required to give you your Miranda warnings. This means if you make statements that can later be used against you, you can’t claim ignorance of your rights.
If you are arrested while at the station, officers will then be required to read you your rights before questioning you. Whether arrested at the station or elsewhere, the smartest thing to do is assert your right to remain silent and ask for an attorney.
Don’t Re-Engage With Police After an Arrest
Let’s say you’ve been arrested and think of something you could say to help your situation, like blaming someone else. This is a bad idea. Once you’ve asserted your right to remain silent, do not re-engage. Volunteering information that later incriminates you can be used against you, even if no one read you your rights.
What Happens If You Talk After Being Read Your Rights?
If you decide to talk to police after being read your rights, you’ve essentially waived those rights. It’s critical to remain silent and speak only through your attorney.
Can Police Use Statements Made by Others Against You?
If police claim that others have given statements, you might feel pressured to give one too. However, it’s always better to let your attorney handle any communication. Anything your lawyer says on your behalf cannot be used against you, while anything you say can and will be used to build a case against you.
Final Thoughts on Miranda Rights
Everyone has heard of Miranda rights thanks to television and movies, but most don’t understand when they apply. Remember, Miranda rights only apply if you’re in custody and being interrogated. If you’re not in custody or voluntarily talking to police, you are not protected by Miranda.
Additionally, you cannot sue police officers for failing to read you your rights. Miranda rights only apply in criminal cases; if the situation isn’t criminal, anything you say can still be used against you.
Key Takeaways for Police Interactions
Here are a few things to keep in mind when dealing with the police:
- Invoke your right to remain silent. You must explicitly tell the officer that you’re invoking this right.
- Clarify your status. If unsure, ask the officer, “Am I detained or free to go?”
- Phone calls don’t count. If you talk to police on the phone, they don’t need to read you your rights.
- Never go to the station alone. If they want to question you, they will find a way.
- Don’t reinitiate contact. Once you’ve asserted your right to remain silent, don’t engage again.
- Never volunteer your phone password. That’s a topic for another video, but it’s a critical tip.
If you remember nothing else, remember this: when in doubt, remain silent and get an attorney. Anything you say can and will be used against you, but nothing your lawyer says can be.
